
.
.JIANG ZEMIN
Jiang Zemin
(born 17 August 1926) is the "core of the third generation" of
Communist Party of China leaders, serving as General Secretary of
the Communist Party of China from 1989 to 2002, as President of
the People's Republic of China from 1993 to 2003, and as Chairman
of the Central Military Commission from 1989 to 2004.
Jiang, an engineer, came to power
in the wake of the
Tiananmen Square protests of 1989, replacing
Zhao Ziyang, who was purged for being too conciliatory towards
the protestors, as General Secretary of Party. With the waning
influence of
Deng Xiaoping and the other members of Eight Elders due to old
age, Jiang effectively became the "paramount leader" in the 1990s.
Under his leadership, China experienced substantial developmental
growth with reforms, saw the peaceful return of Hong Kong from the
United Kingdom and Macau from Portugal, and improved its relations
with the outside world while the Communist Party maintained its
tight control over the government. Jiang has been criticized for
being too concerned about his personal image at home, and too
conciliatory towards Russia and the United States abroad. Critics
also point to Jiang's inability to maintain control on various
social imbalances and problems that surfaced during his term.
Traditionalist communists in China charge Jiang of being a
revisionist leader who legitimized outright capitalism. His
contribution to the Marxist doctrine, a list of guiding ideologies
by which the CCP rules China, is called the theory of the Three
Represents, which has been written into the party and state
constitutions.
Background and ascendancy
Jiang was born in the city of
Yangzhou, Jiangsu. His ancestral home, a notion important in
traditional Chinese society, was the Jiangwan Village, Wuyuan
County of the old Huizhou in northern Jiangxi Province, which was
also the hometown of a number of prominent figures in Chinese
academic and intellectual establishments. Jiang grew up during the
years of Japanese occupation. His uncle, Jiang Shangqing, died
fighting the Japanese, and was considered a martyr. Jiang attended
the National Central University (Department of Radio Engineering
at Southeast University) in the Japanese-occupied Nanjing before
being transferred to Shanghai Jiao Tong University. He graduated
there in 1947 with a Bachelor's degree in electrical engineering.
He claimed that he joined the Communist Party of China when he was
in college (this has never been verified by any individuals or
documents). After the establishment of the People's Republic of
China, Jiang received his training at the Stalin Automobile Works
in Moscow in the 1950s. He worked for Changchun's First Automobile
Works. He eventually got transferred to government services, where
he began rising in rank, becoming a
member of the Central Committee of the Communist Party, Minister
of Electronic Industries in 1983. In 1985 he became Mayor of
Shanghai, and subsequently the Party Chief of Shanghai.
Jiang received mixed reviews as mayor. Many of his critics
dismissed him as a "flower vase", a Chinese term used to describe
a decorative but useless person.
Many credited Shanghai's growth during the period to
Zhu Rongji. Jiang was an ardent believer, during this
period, in
Deng Xiaoping's economic reforms. In an attempt of curbing
student discontent in 1986, Jiang recited the
Gettysburg Address in English in front of a group of student
protesters.
Jiang was described as having a passable command of several
foreign languages, including
Romanian, Russian, and English. One of his favorite activities
was to engage foreign visitors in small talks on art and
literature in their native language, in addition to singing
foreign songs in the original language. He became friends with
Allen Broussard, the African American judge who visited
Shanghai in 1987 and Brazilian actress
Lucelia Santos.
Jiang was elevated to national politics in 1987, automatically
becoming a member of the Politburo of the
CPC Central Committee because it is customarily dictated that
the Party Chief of Shanghai would also have a seat in the
Politburo. In 1989, China was in crisis over the
Tiananmen Square protest, and the Central Government was in
conflict on how to handle the protesters. (The
opening policy, brought out by
Deng Xiaoping, has been proved as a crucial and brilliant
turning point in China's modern history, causing the economy to
grow at an astonishing rate during the past decades.) In June,
Deng Xiaoping dismissed liberal
Zhao Ziyang, who was considered too conciliatory to student
protestors. Jiang, at the time, was the
Shanghai Party Chief, the top figure in China's new economic
center. In an incident with the World Economic Herald,
Jiang closed down the newspaper, deeming it harmful. The handling
of the crisis in Shanghai was noticed by Beijing, and then
paramount Leader Deng Xiaoping. As the protests escalated and then
Party-chief
Zhao Ziyang was removed from office, Jiang was selected by the
Party leaders as a compromise candidate over
Tianjin's
Li Ruihuan, Premier
Li
Peng,
Chen Yun, and the retired elders to become the new General
Secretary. At the time he was considered to be an unlikely
candidate. Within three years Deng had transferred most power in
the state, party and military to Jiang.
Early leadership
Jiang was elevated to the country's top job in 1989 with a
fairly small power base inside the party, and thus, very little
actual power. He was believed as simply a transitional figure
until a more stable successor government to Deng could be put in
place. Other prominent Party and military figures like
Yang Shangkun and brother
Yang Baibing were believed to be planning a coup. Jiang used
Deng Xiaoping as a back-up to his leadership in the first few
years. Jiang, who was believed to have a neo-conservative slant,
warned against "bourgeois liberalization". Deng's belief, however,
stipulated that the only solution to keeping the legitimacy of
Communist rule over China was to continue the drive for
modernization and economic reform, and therefore placed himself at
odds with Jiang.
At the first meeting of the new Standing Committee of the
Politburo, after the Tiananmen Square massacre of 1989, Jiang
criticized the previous period as "hard on the economy, soft on
politics" and advocated increasing political thought work.
Anne-Marie Brady writes that "Jiang Zemin was a long time
political cadre with a nose for ideological work and its
importance. This meeting marked the beginning of a new era in
propaganda and political thought work in China." Soon after, the
Central Propaganda Department was given more resources and power,
"including the power to go in to the propaganda-related work units
and cleanse the ranks of those who had been supportive of the
democracy movement."
Deng grew critical of Jiang's
leadership in 1992. During Deng's southern tours, he subtly
suggested that the pace of reform was not fast enough, and the
"central leadership" (i.e. Jiang) had most responsibility. Jiang
grew ever more cautious, and rallied behind Deng's reforms
completely. In 1993, Jiang coined the new term "Socialist Market
Economy" to move China's centrally-planned socialist economy into
essentially a government-regulated capitalist market economy. It
was a huge step to take in the advancement of Deng's "Socialism
with Chinese characteristics". At the same time, Jiang elevated
many of his supporters from Shanghai to high government positions,
after regaining Deng's confidence. He abolished the outdated
Central Advisory Committee, an advisory body composed of
revolutionary party elders. He became Chairman of the Central
Military Commission in 1989, followed by his election to the
Presidency in March 1993.
Secretaryship and Presidency
Deng Xiaoping died in early 1997,
and China, emerging gradually out of the Deng-era reforms and the
relative stability of the early 1990s, faced a myriad of economic
and social problems. At Deng's funeral, Jiang delivered his
eulogy. He had inherited a China rampant with government
corruption, and regional economies growing too rapidly for the
stability of the entire country. Deng's idea that "some areas can
get rich before others" gave rise to an opening wealth gap between
coastal regions and the hinterlands. The unprecedented economic
growth had inevitably led to the closing of many state-owned
enterprises (SOE's), and a staggering unemployment rate that hit
40% in some urban areas. Stock markets fluctuated greatly. The
scale of rural migration into urban areas was unprecedented
anywhere in the world, and little was being done to address an
ever-increasing urban-rural wealth gap. Official reports put the
figure on the percentage of China's GDP being moved and abused by
corrupt officials at 10%. A chaotic environment of illegal bonds
issued from civil and military officials resulted in much of the
corrupted wealth to end up in foreign countries. Corruption levels
had replicated, if not exceeded that of the Republican era in the
1940s. A surge in crime rates and the re-emergence of organized
crime began to plague cities. A careless stance on the destruction
of the environment furthered concerns voiced by intellectuals.
Jiang's biggest aim in the economy was stability, and he believed
that a stable government with highly centralised power would be a
prerequisite, choosing to postpone political reform, which in many
facets of governance exacerbated the on-going problems. Jiang
continued pouring funds to develop the Special Economic Zones and coastal regions.
Jiang is believed to be the first Chinese leader to truly
manipulate the medium of television to enhance his own image,
gaining a reputation for charisma. Beginning in 1996, Jiang began a series of
reforms in the state-controlled media aimed at promoting the "core
of leadership" under himself, and at the same time crushing some
of his political opponents. The personality enhancements in the
media were largely frowned upon during the Deng era, and had not
been seen since Mao and
Hua Guofeng's time in office in the late 1970s. The
People's Daily and
CCTV-1's 7 p.m. national news each had Jiang-related events as the
front-page or top stories, a fact that remained until Hu Jintao's
media administrative changes in 2006. He appeared casual in front
of Western media, and gave an unprecedented interview with Mike
Wallace of CBS in 2000 at Beidaihe. He would often use foreign
languages in front of the camera, albeit not always
comprehensible. In an encounter with a Hong Kong reporter in 2000
regarding the central government's apparent "imperial order" of
supporting Tung Chee-hwa to seek a second term as Chief Executive
of Hong Kong, Jiang branded the Hong Kong
journalists as "too simple, sometimes naive" in English.
The event was shown on Hong Kong television that night, an event
regarded to be in poor taste outside China.
Since 1999, the media has also played an integral role in the
crackdown of Falun Gong, which Falun Gong groups believe to be
an act under the direction of Jiang himself, and has been heavily
criticized by the West. Jiang reputedly came under conflict with the
more moderate premier
Zhu Rongji over how to contain the spiritual movement. According to International Advocates for
Justice, Falun Gong has filed the largest number of human
rights lawsuits in the 21st century and the charges are among the
most severe international crimes defined by international criminal
laws.
Ownby stated that, 54 civil and criminal lawsuits were under way
in 33 countries in 2006
In December 2009, based on a case brought by Falun Gong followers
in the country four years previously, Argentine Federal Judge
Octavio de Lamadrid issued an arrest warrant for Jiang and Luo Gan
for "crimes
against humanity". The landmark case succeeded because
provisions in Argentina's 1994 constitution allow Argentine courts
to address human rights issues in other countries. The report does
not state whether Luo or Jiang were represented.
Foreign policy
Jiang went on a groundbreaking
state visit to the United States in 1997, drawing various
crowds in protest from the Tibet Independence Movement to the
supporters of Chinese Democracy Movement. He made a speech at
Harvard University, part of it in passable English, but could not
escape questions on democracy and freedom. In the official summit
meeting with US President
Bill Clinton, the tone was relaxed as Jiang and Clinton sought
common ground while largely ignoring areas of disagreement.
Clinton would visit China in June 1998, and vowed that China and
the United States were partners in the world, and not adversaries.
When American-led
NATO bombed the Chinese Embassy in Belgrade in 1999, Jiang
seemed to have put up a harsh stance for show at home, but in
reality only performed symbolic gestures of protest, and no solid
action. Much of Jiang's foreign policy was focused on
international trade and economic integration. A personal friend of
former Canadian Prime Minister
Jean Chrétien,
Jiang strengthened China's economic stature abroad, attempting to
establish cordial relations with countries whose trade is largely
confined to the American economic sphere.
Economic
development
Jiang did not specialize in
economics, and in 1997 handed a big chunk of the economic
governance of the country to Zhu Rongji, who became Premier, and
remained in office through the Asian financial crisis. Under their
joint leadership, Mainland China has sustained an average of 8%
GDP growth annually, achieving the highest rate of per capita
economic growth in major world economies, raising eyebrows around
the world with its astonishing speed. This was mostly achieved by
continuing the process of a transition to a market economy.
Economists, however, charge Jiang with creating a bubble economy
that could fall apart at any time. Strong party control over China
was cemented by the PRC's successful bid to join the World Trade
Organization and Beijing winning the bid to host the 2008 Summer
Olympics.
Entrenching Three Represents
Before he transferred power to a
younger generation of leaders, Jiang had his theory of Three
Represents written into the Party's constitution, alongside
Marxism-Leninism,
Mao
Zedong Thought, and
Deng Xiaoping Theory at the 16th CPC Congress in 2002.
Although contradictory to Marxism and Maoism in many facets, it
was also written into China's Constitution. Critics believe this
is just another piece added to Jiang's cult of personality, others
have seen practical applications of the theory as a guiding
ideology in the future direction of the CPC. Largely speculated to
step down from all positions by international media, rival Li
Ruihuan's resignation in 2002 prompted analysts to rethink
the man. The theory of Three Represents was believed by many
political analysts to be Jiang's effort at extending his vision to
Marxist-Leninist Principles, and therefore elevating himself
alongside previous Chinese Marxist philosophers Mao and Deng.
Gradual
retirement
In 2002, Jiang stepped down from
the powerful Politburo Standing Committee of the Communist Party
of China to make way for a "fourth generation" of leadership
headed by Hu Jintao, marking the beginning of a transition of
power that would last several years. Hu assumed Jiang's title as
party chief, becoming the new general secretary of the Communist
Party. Six out of the nine new members of Standing Committee at
the time were considered part of Jiang's so-called "Shanghai
Clique", the most prominent being Vice President Zeng Qinghong and
Executive Vice Premier Huang Ju.
Although Jiang retained the chairmanship of the powerful
Central Military Commission, most members of the commission
are professional military men. Liberation Army Daily, a
publication thought to represent the views of the CMC majority,
printed an article on 11 March 2003 which quotes two army
delegates as saying, "Having one center is called 'loyalty', while
having two centers will result in 'problems.'" This was widely interpreted as a criticism of
Jiang's attempt to exercise dual leadership with Hu on the model
of Deng Xiaoping.
Hu succeeded Jiang as
president of the People's Republic of China on 15 March 2003.
To the surprise of many observers, evidence of Jiang's continuing
influence on public policy abruptly disappeared from the official
media. Jiang was conspicuously silent during the
SARS crisis, especially when compared to the very public
profile of Hu and
Wen Jiabao. It has been argued that the institutional
arrangements created by the 16th Congress have left Jiang in a
position where he cannot exercise much influence. Although many of the members of the
Politburo Standing Committee are associated with him, the Standing
Committee does not have command authority over the civilian
bureaucracy.
On 19 September 2004, after a four-day meeting of the
198-member
Central Committee, Jiang resigned as chairman of the CPC
Central Military Commission, his last party post. Six months later
he resigned his last significant post, chairman of the State CMC.
This followed weeks of speculation that Hu Jintao's supporters in
the Communist Party leadership were pressing Jiang to step aside.
Jiang's term was supposed to have lasted until 2007. Hu also
succeeded Jiang as the CMC chairman, but, in an apparent political
defeat for Jiang,
Xu Caihou, and not Zeng Qinghong was appointed to succeed Hu
as vice chairman. This power transition officially marks the end
of Jiang's era in China, which roughly lasted from 1993 to 2004.
Although Jiang has been seldom seen in public since giving up
his last official title in 2004, he was with Hu Jintao on stage at
a ceremony celebrating the 80th anniversary of the founding of the
People's Liberation Army,
and toured the Military Museum of the Chinese Peoples Revolution
with Li Peng, Zhu Rongji, and other former senior officials.
On 8 August 2008, Jiang appeared at the opening ceremony of the
Beijing Olympics Games. He also stood beside Hu Jintao during 60th
anniversary of the founding of the People's Republic of China mass
parade in October 2009.
Legacy
Historians and biographers have
disputed what can be accounted into "Jiang Zemin's legacy". Jiang
himself had wanted his Three Represents theory, called an
"important thought" on the Mainland, to become his ideological
legacy. Although the theory has been codified into both the State
and Party constitutions alongside Mao Zedong Thought and Deng
Xiaoping Theory, its actual effect has yet to be
assessed, and it seems to be losing ground to Hu Jintao's
Scientific Development Concept and
Harmonious Society ideologies within the party. Jiang has
come under quiet criticism from within the
Communist Party of China for focusing on economic growth at
all costs while ignoring the resulting environmental damage of the
growth, the widening gap between rich and poor in China and the
social costs absorbed by those whom economic reform has left
behind. By contrast, the policies of his successors,
Hu Jintao and
Wen Jiabao have widely been seen as efforts to address these
imbalances and move away from a sole focus on economic growth
toward a broader view of development which incorporates
non-economic factors such as health and the environment.
Domestically, Jiang's legacy and reputation is mixed. While
some people attribute the period of relative
stability and growth in the 1990s to Jiang's term, others argue
that Jiang did little to correct mistakes resulting from Deng
Xiaoping's economic reforms, leaving the next administration
facing innumerable problems, some of which are too late to adjust. The fact that he arose to power as the
direct beneficiary of the turmoils of 4 June has not been
forgotten by many in China. Indeed, he is in many circles regarded
as a political opportunist; the very model of a new breed of party
members directly associated with the widespread corruption and
cronyism that flourished during his tenure. His interference with
high profile corruption investigations since stepping down from
power, such as those involving Shanghai tycoon Zhou Zhengyi has
only helped to reinforce this perception.
Jiang's obsession with image has also spurred a trend of
face projects around the country, with local governments
lending enormous funds to large and mostly unnecessary
construction projects. While his showy nature has often been
considered charming and even charismatic by the west,
in the relatively more conservative Chinese society it is often
perceived as frivolous, pompous and lacking in character and
substance. Jiang's Theory of Three Represents justified the
incorporation of the new capitalist business class into the party,
and changed the founding ideology of the CPC from protection of
the peasantry and workers to that of the "overwhelming majority of
the people", a euphemism aimed at including the growing
entrepreneurial class. Conservative critics within the party have
quietly denounced this as betrayal of the communist ideology,
while reformers have praised Jiang as a visionary. Such a move, however, increasingly justified
a newly found correlation between the business and ruling elites,
thus significantly linking bureaucracy and financial gain, which
critics argue fosters more corruption. Some have suggested that
this is the part of Jiang's legacy that will last, at least in
name, as long as the communists remain in power.
Many biographers of Jiang have noted that his government
resembled an oligarchy as opposed to an autocratic dictatorship.
Many of his policies have been attributed to others in government, notably Premier
Zhu Rongji, whose tense relationship with Jiang was of
widespread speculation, especially following Jiang's decision to
suppress the
Falun Gong movement. Jiang is often credited with the gains in
foreign affairs during his term,
but at the same many Chinese criticize him for being too
conciliatory towards the United States and Russia. The issue of
Chinese reunification between the mainland and Taiwan gained
ground during Jiang's term, as Cross-Strait talks led to the eventual
Three Links after Jiang stepped down as President. The
Qinghai-Tibet railway began construction under Jiang. The
state-owned press claimed the railway was welcomed by many
Tibetans,
although opposed by pro-independence Tibetans as a purely
political move. Jiang was also accused of appeasement
towards the Japanese and Americans in diplomacy.
|