
.
.Jacques
CHIRAC
Jacques René Chirac
(born 29 November 1932) served as the President of France from 17
May 1995 until 16 May 2007. As President he also served as an
ex officio Co-Prince of Andorra and Grand Master of the French
Légion d'honneur. Chirac was the second-longest serving President
of France (two full terms, first seven years and second five),
behind François Mitterrand. Chirac is the only person to have
served twice as Prime Minister under the Fifth Republic.
His internal policies included
lower tax rates, the removal of price controls, strong punishment
for crime and terrorism, and business privatization. He has also
argued for more socially responsible economic policies, and was
elected in 1995 after campaigning on a platform of healing the
"social rift" (fracture sociale). His economic policies,
based on dirigiste, state directed ideals, stood in
opposition to the laissez-faire policies of the United
Kingdom, which Chirac famously described as "Anglo-Saxon
ultraliberalism".
After completing his studies of
the DEA's degree at the Institut d'études politiques de Paris and
the École nationale d'administration, Chirac began his career as a
high-level civil servant, and soon entered politics. He
subsequently occupied various senior positions, including Minister
of Agriculture, Prime Minister, Mayor of Paris, and finally
President of France.
Family
Chirac, born in the Geoffroy
Saint-Hilaire clinic (Paris Ve), is the son of Abel
François Chirac (1893–1968), a successful executive for an
aircraft company, and Marie-Louise Valette (1902–1973), a
housewife. His great grandparents on both sides were peasants, but
his two grandfathers were teachers from Sainte-Féréole in Corrèze.
According to Chirac, his name "originates from the langue d'oc,
that of the troubadours, therefore that of poetry". He is a Roman
Catholic.
Chirac was an only child (his
elder sister, Jacqueline, died in infancy before his birth), and
was educated in Paris at the Lycée Carnot and at the Lycée
Louis-le-Grand. After his baccalauréat, he served for three months
as a sailor on a coal-transporter.
Chirac played rugby union for
Brive's youth team, and also played at university level. He played
no. 8 and second row.
In 1956, he married Bernadette
Chodron de Courcel, with whom he had two daughters: Laurence (born
4 March 1958) and Claude (14 January 1962). Claude has long worked
as a public relations assistant and personal adviser, while
Laurence, who suffered from anorexia nervosa in her youth, does
not participate in the political activities of her father. Chirac
is the grandfather of Martin Rey-Chirac by the relationship of
Claude with French judoka Thierry Rey. Jacques and Bernadette
Chirac have also a foster daughter, Anh Dao Traxel.
Early political career (1950s–1973)
Inspired by General
Charles de Gaulle, Chirac started to pursue a
civil service career in the 1950s. During this period, he
joined the
French Communist Party, sold copies of
L'Humanité, and took part in meetings of a communist cell.
In 1950, he signed the
Soviet-inspired
Stockholm Appeal for the abolition of
nuclear weapons– which led him to be questioned when he
applied for his first visa to the United States.
In 1953, after graduating from "Sciences
Po", he attended
Harvard University's summer school before entering the École
Nationale d'Administration (ENA), the
Grande école which trains France's top civil servants, in
1957.
Chirac trained as a reserve officer in
armoured cavalry at
Saumur, where he was ranked first among his year.
He then volunteered to fight in the
Algerian War, to be sent there despite the reservations of his
superiors using personal connections. His superiors did not want
to make him an officer due to suspicions of his Communism.
After leaving ENA in 1959, he became a civil servant in the
Court of Auditors. In April 1962, Chirac was appointed head of the
personal staff of Prime Minister
Georges Pompidou. This appointment launched Chirac's political
career. Pompidou considered Chirac his
protégé and referred to him as "my bulldozer" for his skill at
getting things done. The nickname "Le Bulldozer" caught on in
French political circles. Chirac still maintains this reputation.
In 1995 an anonymous British diplomat said Chirac "cuts through
the crap and comes straight to the point...It's refreshing,
although you have to put your seat belt on when you work with
him". At Pompidou's suggestion, Chirac ran as a
Gaullist for a seat in the
National Assembly in 1967. He was elected deputy for his home
Corrèze
département, a stronghold of the left. This surprising
victory in the context of a Gaullist ebb permitted him to enter
the government as
Minister of Social Affairs. Although Chirac was well-situated
in de Gaulle's entourage, being related by marriage to the
general's sole companion at the time of the
Appeal of 18 June 1940, he was more of a "Pompidolian" than a
"Gaullist".
When student and worker unrest rocked France in
May 1968, Chirac played a central role in negotiating a truce.
Then, as state secretary of economy (1968-1971), he had worked
closely with
Valéry Giscard d'Estaing, who headed the ministry of economy
and finance. After some months in the ministry of relations with
Parliament, Chirac's first high-level post came in 1972 when he
became
Minister of Agriculture and rural development under Pompidou,
elected president in 1969. Chirac quickly earned a reputation as a
champion of French farmers' interests, and first attracted
international attention when he assailed U.S., West German, and
European Commission agricultural policies which conflicted
with French interests. On 27 February 1974, after the resignation
of
Raymond Marcellin, Chirac was appointed
Minister of the Interior. On 21 March 1974, he cancelled the
SAFARI project due to privacy concerns after its existence was
revealed by
Le Monde. From March 1974, he was entrusted by President
Pompidou with preparations for the presidential election then
scheduled for 1976. However, these elections were brought forward
because of Pompidou's sudden death on 2 April.
Chirac was behind the vain attempt to rally Gaullists behind
Prime minister
Pierre Messmer.
Jacques Chaban-Delmas announced his candidacy in spite of the
disapproval of the "Pompidolians". Chirac and others published the
call of the 43 in favor of Giscard d'Estaing, the leader of
the non-Gaullist part of the parliamentary majority. Giscard
d'Estaing was elected as Pompidou's successor after France's most
competitive election campaign in years. In return, the new
president chose Chirac to lead the cabinet.
Prime Minister, 1974–76
When
Giscard became president, he nominated Chirac as
prime minister on 27 May 1974 in order to reconcile the
"Giscardian" and "non-Giscardian" factions of the parliamentary
majority. At the age of 41, Chirac stood out as the very model of
the jeunes loups ("young wolves") of French political life,
but he faced with the hostility of the "Barons of Gaullism" who
considered him a traitor for his role during the previous
presidential campaign. In December 1974, he took the lead of the
Union of Democrats for the Republic (UDR) against the will of
its more senior personalities.
As prime minister, Chirac quickly set about persuading the
Gaullists that, despite the social reforms proposed by President
Giscard, the basic tenets of Gaullism, such as national and
European independence, would be retained. Chirac was advised by
Pierre Juillet and
Marie-France Garaud, two former advisers of Pompidou. These
two organised the campaign against Chaban-Delmas in 1974. They
advocated a clash with Giscard d'Estaing because they thought his
policy bewildered the conservative electorate. Citing Giscard's
unwillingness to give him authority, Chirac resigned as Prime
Minister in 1976. He proceeded to build up his political base
among France's several conservative parties, with a goal of
reconstituting the Gaullist UDR into a neo-Gaullist group, the
Rally for the Republic (RPR).
Osirak
controversy
At the invitation of
Saddam Hussein (then vice-president of Iraq,
but de facto dictator), Chirac made an official visit to
Baghdad in 1975. Saddam approved a deal granting French oil
companies a number of privileges plus a 23 per cent share of Iraqi
oil.
As part of this deal, France sold Iraq the
Osirak MTR
nuclear reactor, a type designed to test nuclear materials.
The
Israeli Air Force alleged that the reactor's imminent
commissioning was a threat to its security, and pre-emptively
bombed the Osirak reactor on 7 June 1981, provoking considerable
anger from French officials and the United Nations Security
Council.
The Osirak deal became a controversy again in 2002-2003, when
the United States
decided to invade Iraq. France, with several other European
countries, led an effort to prevent such an invasion. The Osirak
deal was then used by parts of the American media against the
Chirac-led
opposition to starting a war in Iraq.
Mayor of Paris (1977−1995)
After his departure from the cabinet, Chirac wanted to take the
leadership over the right in order to gain the presidency. The RPR
was conceived as an electoral machine against President Giscard
d'Estaing. Paradoxically, Chirac benefited from Giscard's decision
to create the office of mayor in Paris, which had been in abeyance
since the 1871
Commune, because the leaders of the
Third Republic (1871-1940) feared that having municipal
control of the capital would give the mayor too much power. In
1977, Chirac stood as candidate against
Michel d'Ornano, a close friend of the president, and he won.
As mayor of Paris, Chirac's political influence grew. He held this
post until 1995.
Chirac supporters point out that, as mayor, he provided
programs to help the elderly, people with disabilities, and single
mothers, while providing incentives for businesses to stay in
Paris. His opponents contend that he installed "clientelist"
policies, which favored office buildings at the expense of
housing, driving rents high and worsening the situation of
workers.
Chirac has been named in several
cases of alleged corruption that occurred during his term as
mayor, some of which have led to felony convictions of some
politicians and aides. However, a controversial judicial decision
in 1999 granted Chirac immunity while he was president of France.
He refused to testify on these matters, arguing that it would be
incompatible with his presidential functions. Investigations
concerning the running of Paris's city hall, the number of whose
municipal employees jumped by 25% from 1977 to 1995 (with 2000 out
of approximatively 35000 coming from the Corrèze region where
Chirac held his seat as deputy), as well as a lack of transparency
concerning accounts of public tendering (marchés publics) or of
the communal debt, were thwarted by the legal impossibility of
questioning him as president. The conditions of the privatisation
of the Parisian water network, acquired very cheaply by the
Générale and the Lyonnaise des Eaux, then directed by Jérôme
Monod, a close friend of Chirac, were also criticised.
Furthermore, the satirical newspaper Le Canard enchaîné
revealed the high amount of "food expenses" paid by the Parisian
municipality (€15 million a year according to the Canard),
expenses managed by Roger Romani (who allegedly destroyed all
archives of the period 1978–1993 during night raids in 1999-2000).
Thousands of people were invited each year to receptions in the
Paris city hall, while many political, media and artistic
personalities were hosted in private flats owned by the city.
Chirac's immunity from prosecution ended when he left office in
November 2007, when a preliminary charge of misuse of public funds
was filed against him.
Chirac is said to be the first former French head of state to be
formally placed under investigation for a crime.
On 30 October 2009, a judge ordered Chirac to stand trial on
embezzlement charges dating back to his time as mayor of Paris.
Struggle for the right-wing leadership
In 1978, he attacked the
pro-European policy of Valéry Giscard d'Estaing (VGE), and made a
nationalist turn with the December 1978 Call of Cochin, initiated
by his counsellors Marie-France Garaud and Pierre Juillet, which
had first been called by Pompidou. Hospitalised in Cochin hospital
after a crash, he then declared that "as always about the drooping
of France, the pro-foreign party acts with its peaceable and
reassuring voice". Furthermore, he appointed Ivan Blot, an
intellectual who would join later, for some time, the National
Front, as director of his campaigns for the 1979 European
election. After the poor results of the election, Chirac broke
with Garaud and Juillet. Nevertheless, the already-established
rivalry with Giscard d'Estaing became even more intense. Although
it has been often interpreted by historians as the struggle
between two rival French right-wing families, the Bonapartists,
represented by Chirac, and the Orleanists, represented by VGE,
both figures in fact were members of the Liberal, Orleanist
tradition, according to historian Alain-Gérard Slama. But the
eviction of the Gaullist Barons and of President VGE convinced
Chirac to assume a strong neo-Gaullist stance.
Chirac made his first run for president against Giscard
d'Estaing in the
1981 election, thus splitting the centre-right vote. He was
eliminated in the first round (18%) then, he reluctantly supported
Giscard in the second round. He refused to give instructions to
the RPR voters but said that he supported the incumbent president
"in a private capacity", which was almost like a de facto
support of the
Socialist Party's (PS) candidate,
François Mitterrand, who was elected by a broad majority.
Giscard has always blamed Chirac for his defeat. He was told by
Mitterrand, before his death, that the latter had dined with
Chirac before the election. Chirac told the Socialist candidate
that he wanted to "get rid of Giscard". In his memoirs, Giscard
wrote that between the two rounds, he phoned the RPR headquarters.
He passed himself off as a right-wing voter by changing his voice.
The RPR employee advised him "certainly do not vote Giscard!".
After 1981, the relationship between the two men became somewhat
tense, with Giscard, even though he was in the same government
coalition as Chirac, taking opportunities to criticise Chirac's
actions.
After the May 1981 presidential election, the right also lost
the subsequent
legislative election that year. However, as Giscard had been
knocked out, Chirac appeared as the principal leader of the
right-wing opposition. Due to his attacks against the economic
policy of the Socialist government, he progressively aligned
himself with prevailing economic liberal opinion, even if this did
not correspond with the Gaullist doctrine. While the far-right
National Front grew, taking in particular advantage of a
proportional representation electoral law, he signed an
electoral platform with the Giscardian (and more or less Christian
Democrat) party
Union for French Democracy (UDF).
1988 presidential elections and
afterwards
Chirac sought the presidency and
ran against Mitterrand for a second time in the 1988 election. He
obtained 20 percent of the vote in the first round, but lost the
second with only 46 percent. He resigned from the cabinet and the
right lost the next legislative election.
For the first time, his leadership
over the RPR was challenged. Charles Pasqua and Philippe Séguin
criticised his abandonment of Gaullist doctrines. On the right, a
new generation of politicians, the "renovation men", accused
Chirac and Giscard of being responsible for the electoral defeats.
In 1992, convinced a man could not became President whilst
advocating anti-European policies, he called for a "yes" vote in
the referendum on the Maastricht Treaty, against the opinion of
Pasqua, Séguin and a majority of the RPR voters, who chose to vote
"no".
While he still was mayor of Paris
(since 1977), Chirac went to Abidjan (Côte d'Ivoire) where he
supported President Houphouët-Boigny (1960-1993), although the
latter was being called a "thief" by the local population. Chirac
then declared that multipartism was a "kind of luxury."
Nevertheless, the right won the
1993 legislative election. Chirac announced that he did not want
to come back as prime minister, suggesting the appointment of
Edouard Balladur, who had promised that he would not run for the
presidency against Chirac in 1995. However, benefiting from
positive polls, Balladur decided to be a presidential candidate,
with the support of a majority of right-wing politicians. Chirac
broke at that time with a number of friends and allies, including
Charles Pasqua, Nicolas Sarkozy, etc., who supported Balladur's
candidacy. A small group of "fidels" would remain with him,
including Alain Juppé and Jean-Louis Debré. When Nicolas Sarkozy
became President in 2007, Juppé was one of the few "chiraquiens"
to serve in François Fillon's government.
First term as president (1995–2002)
During the 1995 presidential
campaign, Chirac criticised the "sole thought" (pensée unique) of
neoliberalism represented by his challenger on the right and
promised to reduce the "social fracture", placing himself more to
the center and thus forcing Balladur to radicalise himself.
Ultimately, he obtained more votes than Balladur in the first
round (20.8 percent), and then defeated the Socialist candidate
Lionel Jospin in the second round (52.6 percent).
Chirac was elected on a platform
of tax cuts and job programs, but his policies did little to ease
the labor strikes during his first months in office. On the
domestic front, neo-liberal economic austerity measures introduced
by Chirac and his conservative prime minister Alain Juppé,
including budgetary cutbacks, proved highly unpopular. At about
the same time, it became apparent that Juppé and others had
obtained preferential conditions for public housing, as well as
other perks. At the year's end Chirac faced major workers' strikes
which turned itself, in November-December 1995, in a general
strike, one of the largest since May 1968. The demonstrations were
largely pitted against Juppé's plan on the reform of pensions, and
led to the dismissal of the latter.
Shortly after taking office,
Chirac – undaunted by international protests by environmental
groups – insisted upon the resumption of nuclear tests at Mururoa
Atoll in French Polynesia in 1995, a few months before signing the
Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty. Reacting to criticism, Chirac said,
"You only have to look back at 1935...There were people then who
were against France arming itself, and look what happened." On 1
February 1996, Chirac announced that France had ended "once and
for all" its nuclear testing, intending to accede to the
Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty.
Elected as President of the
Republic, he refused to discuss the existence of French military
bases in Africa, despite requests by the Ministry of Defense and
the Quai d'Orsay (Ministry of Foreign Affairs). The French
Army thus remained in Côte d'Ivoire as well as in Omar Bongo's
Gabon.
In 1997, Chirac dissolved
parliament for early legislative elections in a gamble designed to
bolster support for his conservative economic program. But
instead, it created an uproar, and his power was weakened by the
subsequent backlash. The Socialist Party (PS), joined by other
parties on the left, soundly defeated Chirac's conservative
allies, forcing Chirac into a new period of cohabitation with
Jospin as prime minister (1997-2002), which lasted five years.
Cohabitation significantly
weakened the power of Chirac's presidency. The French president,
by a constitutional convention, only controls foreign and military
policy— and even then, allocation of funding is under the control
of Parliament and under the significant influence of the prime
minister. Short of dissolving parliament and calling for new
elections, the president was left with little power to influence
public policy regarding crime, the economy, and public services.
Chirac seized the occasion to periodically criticise Jospin's
government.
Nevertheless, his position was
weakened by scandals about the financing of RPR by Paris
municipality. In 2001, the left, represented by Bertrand Delanoë
(PS), won over the majority in the town council of the capital.
Jean Tiberi, Chirac's successor at the Paris townhall, was forced
to resign after having been put under investigations in June 1999
on charges of trafic d'influences in the HLMs of Paris
affairs (related to the illegal financing of the RPR). Tiberi was
finally expelled from the RPR, Chirac's party, on 12 October 2000,
declaring to the Figaro magazine on 18 November 2000:
"Jacques Chirac is not my friend anymore." After the publication
of the Méry video-tape by Le Monde on 22 September 2000, in
which Jean-Claude Méry, in charge of the RPR's financing, directly
accused Chirac of organizing the network, and of having been
physically present on 5 October 1986, when Méry gave in cash 5
millions Francs, which came from companies who had benefited from
state deals, to Michel Roussin, personal secretary (directeur
de cabinet) of Chirac, Chirac refused to follow up his summons
by judge Eric Halphen, and the highest echelons of the French
justice declared that he could not been inculpated while in
functions.
During his two terms, he increased
the Elysee Palace's total budget by 105 percent (currently €90
million, whereas 20 years ago it was the equivalent of
€43.7 million). He doubled the number of presidential cars -
nowadays there are 61 cars and seven scooters in the Palace's
garage. He has hired 145 extra employees - the total number of the
people he employed simultaneously was 963.
Defense policy
As the Supreme Commander of the French armed forces, he has
reduced the French military budget, as did his predecessor. It now
accounts for three percent of
GDP.
In 1998 the aircraft carrier
Clemenceau was decommissioned after 37 years of service, and
another aircraft carrier was decommissioned two years later after
37 years of service, leaving the French Navy with no aircraft
carrier until 2001, when
Charles de Gaulle aircraft carrier was commissioned.
He has also reduced expenditures on nuclear weapons
and the French nuclear arsenal now includes 350 warheads, which
can be compared to the Russian nuclear arsenal that consists of
16,000 warheads.
He has also published a plan which assumes reducing the number of
fighters the French military has by 30.
Second term as president (2002–2007)
At the age of 69, Chirac faced his fourth presidential
campaign in 2002. He was the first choice of fewer than one in
five voters in the first round of voting of the
presidential elections in April 2002. It had been expected
that he would face incumbent prime minister
Lionel Jospin (PS) in the second round of elections; instead,
Chirac faced controversial
far right politician
Jean-Marie Le Pen of
National Front (FN), and so won re-election by a landslide (82
percent); all parties outside the National Front (except for
Lutte ouvrière) had called for opposing Le Pen, even if it
meant voting for Chirac. Slogans such as "vote for the crook, not
for the fascist" or "vote with a clothespin on your nose"
appeared, while huge demonstrations marked the period between the
two electoral rounds in all of France. Chirac became increasingly
unpopular during his second term. According to a July 2005 poll,
32 percent judged Chirac favorably and 63 percent unfavorably. In
2006,
The Economist wrote that Chirac "is the most unpopular
occupant of the Elysée Palace in the fifth republic's history."
Early term
As the left-wing Socialist Party
was in thorough disarray following Jospin's defeat, Chirac
reorganised politics on the right, establishing a new party —
initially called the Union of the Presidential Majority, then the
Union for a Popular Movement (UMP). The RPR had broken down; A
number of members had formed Eurosceptic breakaways. While the
Giscardian liberals of the Union of French Democracy (UDF) had
moved to the right. The UMP won the parliamentary elections that
followed the presidential poll with ease.
During an official visit to
Madagascar on 21 July 2005, Chirac described the repression of
the 1947
Malagasy uprising, which left between 80,000 and 90,000 dead,
as "unacceptable".
Despite past opposition to state intervention the Chirac
government approved a 2.8 billion euro
aid package to troubled manufacturing giant
Alstom. In October 2004, Chirac
signed a
trade agreement with PRC President
Hu Jintao where Alstom was given one billion euro in contracts
and promises of future investment in China.
Assassination
attempt
On 14 July 2002, during Bastille
Day celebrations, Chirac survived an assassination attempt by a
lone gunman with a rifle hidden in a guitar case. The would-be
assassin fired a shot toward the presidential motorcade, before
being overpowered by bystanders. The gunman, Maxime Brunerie,
underwent psychiatric testing; the violent far-right group with
which he was associated, Unité Radicale, was then administratively
dissolved.
Stroke
In early September 2005, he suffered an event that his doctors
described as a 'vascular incident'. It was reported as a 'minor
stroke'
or a mini-stroke (also known as a
Transient ischemic attack).
He recovered and returned to his duties soon after.
2005
referendum on the TCE
On 29 May 2005, a
referendum was held in France to decide whether the country
should ratify the proposed treaty for a
Constitution of the European Union (TCE). The result was a
victory for the No campaign, with 55 percent of voters rejecting
the treaty on a turnout of 69 percent, dealing a devastating blow
to Chirac and the
UMP party, as well as to part of the center-left which had
supported the TCE.
Foreign policy
Along with Gerhard Schröder,
Chirac emerged as a leading voice against the Bush
administration's conduct towards Iraq. Despite intense US
pressure, Chirac threatened to veto, at that given point, a
resolution in the UN Security Council that would authorise the use
of military force to rid Iraq of alleged weapons of mass
destruction, and rallied other governments to his position. "Iraq
today does not represent an immediate threat that justifies an
immediate war", Chirac said on 18 March 2003. Chirac was then the
target of various American and British commentators supporting the
decisions of Bush and Tony Blair. Future Prime Minister Dominique
de Villepin acquired much of his popularity for his speech against
the war at the United Nations (UN). However, following
controversies concerning the CIA's black sites and extraordinary
rendition program, the press revealed that French special services
had cooperated with Washington in the same time that Villepin was
countering US foreign policy at the UN headquarters in New York.
After Togo's leader Gnassingbé
Eyadéma's death on 5 February 2005, Chirac gave him tribute and
supported his son, Faure Gnassingbé, who has since succeeded to
his father.
On 19 January 2006, Chirac said
that France was prepared to launch a nuclear strike against any
country that sponsors a terrorist attack against French interests.
He said his country's nuclear arsenal had been reconfigured to
include the ability to make a tactical strike in retaliation for
terrorism.
In July 2006, the G8 met to
discuss international energy concerns. Despite the rising
awareness of global warming issues, the G8 focuses on "energy
security" issues. Chirac continues to be the voice within the G8
summit meetings to support international action to curb global
warming and climate change concerns. Chirac warns that "humanity
is dancing on a volcano" and calls for serious action by the
world's leading industrialised nations.
The
Clearstream affair
During April and May 2006, Chirac's administration was beset by
a crisis as his chosen Prime Minister, Dominique de Villepin, was
accused of asking
Philippe Rondot, a top level French
spy, for a secret investigation into the latter's chief
political rival,
Nicolas Sarkozy, in 2004. This matter has been called the
second
Clearstream Affair. On 10 May 2006, following a Cabinet
meeting, Chirac made a rare television appearance to try to
protect Villepin from the scandal and to debunk allegations that
Chirac himself had set up a Japanese bank account containing 300
million francs in 1992 as Mayor of Paris.
Chirac said that "The Republic is not a dictatorship of rumors, a
dictatorship of calumny."
Announcement of intention not to seek a third term
In a pre-recorded television broadcast aired on 11 March 2007,
Jacques Chirac announced, in a widely-predicted move, that he
would not choose to seek a third term as France's President.
"Serving France, and serving peace, is what I have committed my
whole life to", Chirac said, adding that he would find new ways to
serve France after leaving office. He did not explain the reasons
for his decision.
Chirac did not, during the broadcast, endorse any of the
candidates running for election, but did devote several minutes of
his talk to a plea against extremist politics that was considered
a thinly-disguised invocation to voters not to vote for
Jean-Marie Le Pen and a recommendation to
Nicolas Sarkozy not to orient his campaign so as to include
themes traditionally associated with Le Pen.
|